• Home
  • Puppy Training
  • Dog Training
  • Behaviour Consulting
  • Resources
    • Out and About >
      • Melbourne's off leash parks
      • Park & Walk reviews
    • Training
    • Behaviour Problems
    • Health & Husbandry
    • Blog
  • About us
    • About Positive Training
    • Meet your Trainer
    • Meet the Experts
  • Contact
DeltaDogz - Purely Positive Real Life Training

How breed stereotyping stops effective training

5/23/2011

0 Comments

 
Sighthounds can't be trained to come back, because they compulsively follow everything that moves, being sighthounds. Beagles and other hounds are the same with regards to scents. Alaskan Malamutes (the most wolf like of all the dogs) must be dominated, relegated to the absolute bottom of the pack, otherwise they will try to lead the pack. Collies are great with kids. Pitbulls are bred to be aggressive and must be ruled by a firm hand.

These and other breed stereotypes have condemned a great many dogs to miserable lives. Owners of whippets and greyhounds never even try to train a recall, forcing their dogs to forever walk at human pace, depriving them of the exercise they were bred for, and of any social interaction. 

Alaskan Malamutes, presumably because they are so wolf-like, are "trained" by using plenty of aversives to ensure they don't consider themselves the leaders. Some of the Malamutes treated in this fashion end up so stunted in their ability to offer any behaviour, for fear of the ensuing punishment, that even the most positive training approach may not be able to undo the damage, at least in the short term, see here for an example.

Collies and other dogs supposedly "naturally" good with kids may therefore not get exposed to kids enough during their critical socialisation period early in life, and may end up fearful of children, or even aggressive. Any dog requires thorough socialisation, ie exposure to plenty of different things in their environment, including children, in a way that ensures a positive experience for them, in order to set them up to be truly "good with kids" and other things in the world. 

Breeds do come with certain characteristics of course, but these revolve around what they were bred for in the first place. It is true that sighthounds will be more attracted to chasing that bird or rabbit than a beagle, who is more likely to use his nose to follow a scent, being a scent hound. However, all this means is that you need to structure your training to work with these breed traits. 

Read more about specific training tips for some of the most maligned breeds!
0 Comments

    Daniela Pelgrim

    I started my dog journey with Jessie, a small white fluffball bichon-schnauzer cross. She was trained in the traditional way by choke collar and praise via voice. After she died, Giro, my smooth collie, taught me how wrong this approach was. Kiara, my whippet, reaped all the benefits, and can't wait for her training every day, all day!

    Categories

    All
    Alaskan Malamute
    Body Halter
    Bonding
    Breed Characteristics
    Breed Specific Training Tips
    Calming Signals
    Cat
    Child Friendly Breeds
    Clicker Training
    Collie
    Dog Bite
    Electric Shock Collars
    Fetch
    Head Halter
    Kiara
    Leave It
    Loose Leash Walking
    Newspaper
    Off Leash
    Pit Bull
    Puppies
    Puppy Farm
    Rear End Sensitivity
    Recall
    Recall Exercise
    Rspca
    Scruff Shake
    Sighthounds
    Sit
    Snake Avoidance
    Stray Dogs
    Treats
    Tricks

    RSS Feed

Proudly powered by Weebly